Scientific Peer-review: Providing Critical and Kind Feedback and Advocating for Open Science
Type
Blog Post
...literature. I think that delivering constructive critique can help your colleagues at the receiving end, if not...open science in your peer-review
Additionally, you can ask that data and resources described in the manuscript...journal you are reviewing for. The code and the data can be deposited in the public on-line repository (like...resources, like constructs or biological material, can be deposited in the specific repositories (Addgene... authors.” By addressing the comments to “you” I can easily check if I would have formulated specific ...