Scientific Peer-review: Providing Critical and Kind Feedback and Advocating for Open Science
Type
Blog Post
Published
Aug. 8, 2019, 1:19 p.m.
...to address the comments to “you” rather than “the authors.” By addressing the comments to “you” I can ... figures). After finishing my section-specific comments, I re-read what I wrote about the paper after ...in the first (and clunky) version of my general comments and adjust them if my opinion changed after this...that there is another human who is reading your comments. Receiving a peer-review is already a humbling...young scientists that are reading your peer-review comments will learn from them and propagate this culture...ratio in Arabidopsis, (2) expression patterns in plants with enhanced sodium accumulation in their roots...